Zip ads, brutally reviewed.
Zip is running 13 live ads on LinkedIn and Google. Their average fit to their own ideal buyer is 5.7 out of 10, and 10 ads need fixing. Each ad below is one of Zip’s real live creatives, read straight from the ad libraries.
Zip’s live ads, scored against their buyer
- ππ§'π¦ π£π’ππππ¦π§ π§ππ π! Michael Denari hosts SPEND SIGNAL, a new podcas, scored 6/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Podcast launch is on-brand for procurement but copy gives no reason to tune in beyond the format itself.
- Four years ago, I bought a Shure microphone thinking I would start a podcast on , scored 5/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Personal hook is relatable but the story teaser never connects the anecdote to a procurement insight or product bridge.
- comcast.com | See what intake could look like for you, scored 6/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Clever wordplay reframes procurement as an ally but stays too abstract with no outcome, proof, or clear next step.
- A year ago, AI took about one dollar in every $70 that companies spend on softwa, scored 7/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Proprietary Zip data chart is a strong non-obvious finding but the bridge to procurement action is implicit.
- Earlier this year, the βSaaSpocalypseβ threatened a bleak scenario for software , scored 7/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Zip Enterprise AI Index data is genuinely original and non-obvious, but the link to procurement workflow is left for the reader to infer.
- AI Procurement Platform, Modern Procurement Platform, scored 6/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Covers the right query and full workflow but repeats category labels instead of a specific outcome to differentiate.
- AI Procurement Software Real AI Agent, scored 5/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Matches high-intent query but 'Real AI agent' is a claim without any specific outcome or proof to separate it from category noise.
- AI for Procurement Intuitive Platform, scored 5/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Buyer-relevant terms land but 'streamline vendor relationships' is generic and no outcome or CTA pushes the searcher to act.
- AI-powered Vendor Management, scored 5/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Sitelinks segment buyers well but the headline and body offer no specific outcome, leaving the value proposition thin.
- Zip AI Procurement Platform, scored 6/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Intake-to-pay framing matches the ICP pain precisely but no proof, number, or CTA converts the searcher's intent into action.
- Procurement Platform Modern Vendor Portal, scored 4/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Headline leads with 'Modern Vendor Portal' which undersells the full platform and the body adds no outcome or differentiator.
- Procure-to-Pay Modern Spend Solution, scored 7/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Intake-to-pay body copy and a 'Zip Vs Coupa' sitelink together cover the ICP pain and bottom-funnel comparison intent well.
- AI for Procurement Vendor Portal, scored 5/10 against Zip’s ideal buyer. Feature list in the body covers real ICP pain points but reads as a bullet dump with no specific outcome or CTA to close the click.
See Zip’s full live-ad board on AdRoast. Every creative scored against their ICP, with the exact fix for each.
Learn the method behind these scores: the AdRoast guides cover how to audit your ads against your ICP and why clicks do not turn into pipeline.