Where Signifyd's ads lose the buyer
Signifyd is running 18 live ads on LinkedIn and Google. Their average fit to their own ideal buyer is 6.7 out of 10, and 6 ads need fixing. Each ad below is one of Signifyd’s real live creatives, read straight from the ad libraries.
Signifyd’s live ads, scored against their buyer
- Play the Holiday Arcade & Win Rewards, scored 5/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Gamified engagement hook lands the brand but delivers no product value or conversion reason.
- Approve More Orders, Guaranteed, scored 8/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Sharp scenario, direct comparison claim, and a guarantee land the core ICP pain with real conviction.
- Departamento, scored 6/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Clear ICP outcome stated well but no proof, no number, and the CTA is a tagline rather than a next step.
- Test Our Checkout Process. Claim a Gift Card., scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Smart experiential CTA lowers barrier to trial but skips any outcome proof for the ICP buyer.
- Eletrônicos, scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Sharp false-decline framing for a high-fraud vertical.
- Moda, scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Vivid false-decline visual and sharp hook nail the core ICP pain but no proof or specific outcome is offered.
- Departamento, scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Provocative false-decline question hits the ICP pain precisely but no outcome, number, or next step is given.
- Zero Chargeback Liability, scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Memorable headline and three concrete benefit pillars land well but 'Learn More' CTA undersells the guarantee claim.
- Test Our Checkout Process. Claim a Gift Card., scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Seasonal urgency and experiential gift-card hook are clever but the ICP outcome is implied, not stated, and proof is absent.
- Departamento, scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Punchy seasonal rhythm and direct challenge to the buyer's current tool hit the ICP pain well but no proof or outcome follows.
- Moda, scored 6/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Fraud-risk framing for electronics is on-segment but the creative copy stops at the problem with no outcome or next step.
- Zero Manual Order Reviews, scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Sharp before/after creative nails the operational pain but lacks any proof number to close the deal.
- Eletrônicos, scored 6/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Covers the full fraud journey for electronics buyers but the value claim stays generic with no outcome or proof.
- Moda, scored 6/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Punchy account-takeover hook for fashion is on-segment but stops at the problem with no outcome or next step.
- Moda, scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Bracketing hook lands a real margin pain for fashion fraud leaders but offers no proof or specific outcome.
- Seguridad digital sin fricción, scored 7/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Headline pairs frictionless security with guaranteed protection against chargebacks and abusive returns, hitting the core ICP pain cleanly.
- Signifyd can help, scored 5/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Guarantee of more approvals and zero chargeback liability is the right promise but the headline is too vague to earn the click.
- Detect Return Abuse in Seconds, scored 8/10 against Signifyd’s ideal buyer. Speed claim plus dual promise of fast-tracking valid returns and blocking abuse matches high-intent query precisely.
See Signifyd’s full live-ad board on AdRoast. Every creative scored against their ICP, with the exact fix for each.
Learn the method behind these scores: the AdRoast guides cover how to audit your ads against your ICP and why clicks do not turn into pipeline.